First, you might be wondering what a fire commissioner does. Here’s what the RCW (52.14.010) has to say on the matter:
The affairs of the district shall be managed by a board of fire commissioners composed . . . of registered voters residing in the district. . . . The board shall fix the compensation to be paid the secretary and all other agents and employees of the district. The board may, by resolution adopted by unanimous vote, authorize any of its members to serve as volunteer firefighters without compensation. A commissioner actually serving as a volunteer firefighter may enjoy the rights and benefits of a volunteer firefighter.
And here’s some more information from RCW 52.14.100:
The board has the power and duty to adopt a seal of the district, to manage and conduct the business affairs of the district, to make and execute all necessary contracts, to employ any necessary services, and to adopt reasonable rules to govern the district and to perform its functions, and generally to perform all such acts as may be necessary to carry out the objects of the creation of the district.
In other words, a fire commissioner has a lot of say over what happens to your Fire Department. In fact, because fire protection districts are political subdivisions of the state and municipal corporations, the commissioners are the sole authorities on administrative operations.
In this election, for which you have probably already received your ballot, there are four (out of five) fire commissioner positions open on Bainbridge Island. Positions 2 and 5 are six-year terms, position 3 is a four-year term, and position 5 is a two-year term. So whatever happens has the potential to have a large impact on the Department.
So how do you decide?
Your answer to the following questions should help you decide among the competing candidates:
- Is it a good or a bad thing for the candidate who will oversee the “affairs of the department” to be a member of the department?
- Is it more important for the candidate to have firefighting experience or managerial experience?
Here is information provided by the candidates to the Kitsap County Auditor to help guide your decision:
Commissioner Position 2 (6-Year Term)
YongSuk Cho (Nonpartisan) I am a first generation immigrant. I came to Bainbridge Island at the age of 17 from South Korea in 1988. I have been a resident in Bainbridge Island for 26 years. My Fire and EMS experience include: 22 years as a volunteer firefighter/EMT for Bainbridge Island Fire Department; 14 years as a career firefighter/EMT for Seattle Fire Department; 8 years as a member of FEMA-Disaster Medical Assistance Team (Federal deployments include the Atlanta Olympic bombing, North Dakota flooding, and Northridge earthquake); 7 years as a volunteer/EMT for Bainbridge Island Ambulance.
Statement: Bainbridge Island Fire Department has a long and proud history of providing the highest quality of emergency services to its citizens. The fire stations on Bainbridge Island are staffed by the most dedicated professionals (both Career and Volunteer) that I have ever known. I have had the honor and privilege of serving the citizens of Bainbridge Island for the last 22 years as a volunteer firefighter among those professionals. As a member of the Bainbridge Island Fire Department, I have been involved in the Cadet program, the Resident program, Technical Rescue program, Training program, and various committees involving policy changes and capital improvements. In the coming years, the Department will need to make difficult decisions regarding staffing, capital improvements, and emphasis in different programs. I hope to use my knowledge and experience to help make optimal decisions regarding these issues, and to continue to improve the high quality services provided to the citizens of Bainbridge Island.
David H. Lynch (Nonpartisan) David Lynch, Ph.D., worked at the National Cancer Institute and the University of Utah Medical School before moving to Bainbridge Island in 1988. He lives with his wife and 14-year-old stepdaughter. He has written articles for numerous scientific publications and spoken at international symposia. He has served on both governmental and corporate scientific advisory boards and grant review committees. Locally he has served on the Bainbridge Island Harbor Commission and played a significant role in obtaining a $2M settlement from the Washington State Ferry system that has been designated for waterfront improvement projects on the Island.
Statement: I’ve lived on Bainbridge Island for 25 years. In the past 2 years I had the opportunity to spend significant time with the last Business Administrator for the Bainbridge Island Fire Department and to discuss many aspects of the Department: its operations, needs and challenges. Currently there is a significant “change in the guard” occurring with the turnover of 3 of the 5 Commission seats, and thus a need for strong guidance to ensure the Island has a vibrant Department that provides optimal coverage while remaining fiscally prudent. My educational and corporate experiences will be of value in solving both the current challenges the Department faces and providing critical oversight and guidance in creating and implementing a financially viable strategic development plan for the future. As current Fire Department plans include asking voters for additional funds, it is imperative that the new Board be free from perceived conflicts of interests such as having family members work for the Department or vying for future employment with the Department. The Department has made significant strides in becoming more professional and providing increased services. As a Commissioner, I am committed to continuing that trend.
Commissioner Position 3 (4-Year Unexpired Term)
Dan Morrow (Nonpartisan) I am a lifelong Kitsap County resident, over 27 years of which I have lived on Bainbridge Island. I currently serve as Chair of the Bainbridge Island Fire Department Board of Commissioners and in the past have served Bainbridge Island as a volunteer firefighter/EMT and as a career firefighter/EMT. I hold a B.A. in Economics from the University of Washington. I have worked as an Equity Trader/ Financial Analyst and served as CFO of a successful law firm specializing in medical malpractice and personal injury cases.
Statement: In the role of Fire Commissioner I will continue to champion for fiscal accountability through ongoing financial and process audits while balancing an expectation of high levels of service for career and volunteers of BIFD alike. I strongly support prevention through public education and continued training for all personnel. I also encourage the development of strong inter-agency relationships with the hope of opportunities for shared resources thus reducing the overall tax burden Bainbridge Island citizens will experience.
Commissioner Position 4 (6-Year Term)
William (Bill) Ruddick (Nonpartisan) I have worked as a controller, general manager, and vice president in large corporations and have consulted to over 150 companies in 10 different countries. Past president and board member of the National Wood Window and Door Association. Graduated from the University of Puget Sound with degrees in Business Administration and Economics. Board member and Vice President of Accelerate Kitsap, Past President and Board member of Sunset Hills Water Association, volunteer for Bainbridge Island Chamber of Commerce.
Statement: I have lived on the Island for over 30 years. My goal is to assist the Fire Department to address the critical issues facing us in external, internal, and financial areas in order to be prepared not just for today, but also in the future. Objectives will include the maintenance and growth of a strong and dependable volunteer program to keep costs down and assist our career firefighters. This will also enhance the ability to better cover the spikes in both cars and people due to increasing ferry traffic.
Eileen A. McSherry (Nonpartisan) Eileen McSherry, a long-time resident of Bainbridge Island, serves as Manager of Human Resources for Central Kitsap Fire and Rescue. She has served in Senior Management positions for the Social Security Administration and worked in Labor and Employee Relations for the Navy. Specializing in Conflict Resolution, Human Resources and Communications, Eileen has Masters in Public Administration and in Counseling, both from Seattle University. As personnel costs make up most of the costs of running the Fire Department, she looks forward to offering her expertise to ensure that the department financial and personnel practices best serve the population of Bainbridge Island.
Statement: My priorities as Commissioner will include: Maintaining the role of volunteers: The Bainbridge Island Fire Department has evolved from a primarily volunteer organization to a combined department with volunteers and career professionals. Maintaining the role of volunteers will be one of my priorities. Expanding Service: Ensuring the Department continues to expand services to the northend of the island and maintains appropriate funding. In 2009 the Department adopted plans to staff both the northend and the southend fire stations but, to date, has only staffed the southend. Optimizing new opportunities: The Fire Service is entering a period of rapid changes as federal mandates and incentives will change the way care is provided. My background will allow me to help Bainbridge Island navigate these changes in the most advantageous fashion. Rigorous Planning: I will ensure that the allocation of resources for personnel, equipment and facilities is integrated and well planned. Transparency: Since the Fire Department is a public agency using public funds, I will ensure that the Department meets the highest standards of accountability and transparency with the adoption of comprehensive performance measures. Labor Relations: I will promote collaborative working relations between management and the union.
Commissioner Position 5 (2-Year Unexpired Term)
Holly vanSchaick (Nonpartisan) Holly is a Nationally Certified Firefighter and Washington State Certified Paramedic. She began her career in emergency medical response starting as a volunteer emergency medical technician (EMT) with the Bainbridge Island Ambulance Association and went on to become a career Firefighter and Paramedic. She has had the opportunity to work in a variety of urban and rural environments and has experienced firsthand the challenges met by the departments and the needs of the community. Her professional experience includes Kitsap, Yakima, Clallam and Skagit Counties. Holly is also a busy parent raising four children on Bainbridge Island.
Statement: I will benefit the Board of Commissioners by offering the insight of a currently active emergency response professional, island homeowner and parent. I am passionate about my work and want to give back to this vibrant community in the best way possible. As a mother raising four children on Bainbridge, it’s a personal concern to me that my children are in the care of the best possible emergency services should the need ever arise. Joining the Board would allow me to bring my diverse experiences home and combine them with the unique geography and resources of our beautiful island.
Theresa (Teri) Dettmer (Nonpartisan) I had the pleasure of practicing law for twenty-five years in the areas of health care, employment relations, risk management, insurance defense and professional responsibility. My practice involved representation of individuals, corporations and governmental entities, including physicians, hospitals, state government, county government, city government and fire districts. As a law firm partner, I helped manage budgets, resources and employees to maximize the outcome for all involved. I have lived on Bainbridge Island for over eighteen years, and my husband and I have two children at Bainbridge High School.
Statement: The commissioners are responsible for managing the department’s $7.4 million budget and making such decisions as whether to submit levy requests to the voters and at what amount, whether to construct and/or remodel fire department facilities, and how to staff stations, including the now unstaffed Phelps Road station. This undertaking requires commissioners with significant managerial and administrative experience, as well as an understanding of the law governing the department. As a commissioner, I would assure the department continued to provide the premium level of emergency services we currently enjoy, while searching for ways to improve and be more cost effective. My priorities include employing maximum transparency in all transactions, assisting residents with disaster preparedness, and maintaining a strong volunteer program. Almost 80% of the calls to the department are for medical services, and I look forward to using my years of experience representing health care providers to assist the department’s mission to provide emergency care in a safe and speedy manner. I am especially committed to staffing the Phelps Road station to ensure that residents in the northern part of the island have the same access to swift medical services as now enjoyed by us south end residents.
Commissioner Glen Tyrell resigned in April, and his position has remained open since then. The terms of Commissioners Paul Bang Knudsen, Maureen Halligan, and Dan Morrow are ending. Morrow replaced Susan Cohen who stepped down in April of 2012.
Photo by Sarah Lane.